
The difference between oilless screw and oil-injected screw air compressor
Oil-free screw air compressors and oil-injected screw air compressors are two types of screw compressors. The main differences lie in the lubrication method, compressed air quality and application scenarios. The following is a detailed comparison from three aspects: design principles, performance characteristics, and application scenarios:
1. design principle
- Oil-free screw air compressor:
- lubrication method: Use self-lubricating materials (such as special coatings or wear-resistant ceramics) instead of lubricating oils to reduce friction by optimizing screw geometry and sealing structure.
- cooling mechanism: Rely on water cooling or air cooling systems to control temperature to avoid material wear caused by high temperatures.
- structural characteristics: Precision machining is needed to ensure rotor clearance sealing. Some models adopt two-stage compression design to reduce single-stage compression ratio.
- Oil injection screw air compressor:
- lubrication method: Lubricating oil is injected into the compression chamber through the oil injection system, realizing the triple functions of lubrication, cooling and sealing at the same time.
- cooling mechanism: Lubricating oil circulation removes compression heat, and oil cooler assists in heat dissipation.
- structural characteristics: The meshing gap between the male and female rotors is large and relies on oil film sealing. An oil-gas separator is needed to remove oil in the exhaust gas.
2. Performance characteristics comparison
performance Index | oil-free screw compressor | oil-injected screw compressor |
---|---|---|
compressed air quality | Completely oil-free and meets Class 0 standards | Contains trace amounts of oil (usually ≤3ppm), requires post-treatment equipment |
efficiency | Low single-stage compression ratio and high two-stage compression efficiency | High single-stage compression ratio and better energy efficiency ratio |
noise and vibration | Low noise (no oil film disturbance), low vibration | Low noise (lubricating oil noise reduction), good vibration control |
maintenance costs | No need to replace lubricating oil and filter elements, low maintenance costs | Lubricating oil, filter elements and oil-gas separators need to be replaced regularly |
life | Depends on material wear resistance, life is affected by working conditions | Lubricating oil extends equipment life and is suitable for continuous high-load operation |
cost | High initial investment (special materials/precision machining) | Low initial investment and high long-term operation and maintenance costs |
3. application scenarios
- oil-free screw compressor:
- Industries requiring high cleanliness:
- food and beverage: Process gases that come into direct contact with the product (e.g. filling, packaging).
- the field of pharmaceutical drugs: Clean compressed air in compliance with GMP regulations (fermentation, mixing, packaging).
- electronic semiconductor: Cleaning and drying processes in chip manufacturing (to avoid oil pollution).
- special environment:
- Low/high temperature extreme conditions (no risk of oil freezing or carbonization).
- Explosion-proof locations (oil-free systems reduce explosion risks).
- Industries requiring high cleanliness:
- oil-injected screw compressor:
- General industrial scenarios:
- manufacturing: Drive pneumatic tools and automated production lines.
- construction industry: Concrete spraying, pneumatic equipment air supply.
- chemical industry: Gas transportation and reaction in the process.
- High-load continuous operation:
- Mining (gas supply from rock drills and drilling rigs).
- Power plant (instrument air source, pneumatic ash conveying).
- General industrial scenarios:
4. technology development trend
- oil-free screw compressor:
- new material application: Graphene coating and ceramic composite materials improve wear resistance.
- intelligent monitoring: Predictive maintenance of integrated vibration sensors.
- oil-injected screw compressor:
- Oil quality optimization: Synthetic lubricants improve high temperature stability.
- modular design: Multiple machines are connected in parallel to achieve dynamic adjustment of energy efficiency.
summary
Selection suggestions | Priority is given to oil-free screws | Preference for oil injection screws |
---|---|---|
core needs | The compressed air is absolutely oil-free | Optimal comprehensive energy efficiency and cost |
typical scenario | Pharmaceutical clean room, electronic workshop | Mechanical processing, construction sites |
investment preferences | Long term low maintenance costs | Initial low-cost investment |